1991-2004

Manuscript Draft

  • No Calypso This Time Request MSWord doc: bwicinas@pacbell.net

  • From 1991 through 2004 the school district of Berkeley twice reinvented its school integration. When its home-spun socio-economic integration system survived a court challenge in 2004 it made national news. It prevailed in court twice more through 2009, persists today and is even cited by parents as a motive for residing there.

    Superintendents of other districts, seeking a formula for replication, have asked “what kind of ‘bench strength’ was needed?” Journalists typically declare “they [the school district] came up with X” as if it was just another day's routine work of bureaucrats.  This shrinks to insignificance a story that defies presumption. There was no “bench strength.” The birth spanned many years and successive casts. The credit belongs largely to the patience and persistence of volunteers, mostly female.

    Why has it been durable? I am taught by 25 year hindsight.  A social device which contracts citizens to sacrifice must be owned by the citizens. Hence it must be authored by them. They must believe they can do it and that there exists a method that fits. There is little return in writing a manual for experts. For an audience of motivated “regular folk” I have crafted, I hope, a lively narrative.

    In the national conversation I hear only uninformed assertions about how such a puzzle gets solved and its solution embraced. I hear no voice which appears to have learned from a like experience.

    For the few who have interest in the “hands on”, a “tech topics” appendix outlines the mechanics we devised.


  • Controlled Choice Solutions website (dormant)
  • KQED Interview October 2016
  • Scans of clippings and docs pertaining to Berkeley Unified Desegregation Deliberations

    Ancient

  • 591012_STAATSCommitteeReportOnInterracialProblems.pdf
  • 630900_DefactoSeg_ReportOfCitizensCommittee.pdf
  • 63fall_RacialIsolationStudiedInBerkSchools.pdf
  • 640500_FeasibilityOfDeseg.pdf
  • 661100_SurveyOfAttitudesTowardBussing.pdf

  • Chronical_60sDesegEvents.pdf
  • ChronicleOfEvents60sDeseg.pdf
  • NeverADull_0_28_TheGoodOldDays.pdf
  • NeverADull_125_168_AllOftheChildren.pdf
  • NeverADull_203_248_ReportCard1972.pdf
  • NeverADull_29_62_GiantStepForward.pdf
  • NeverADull_63_96_Entr_acte196401967.pdf
  • NeverADull_97_124_64_dollar_question.pdf
  • First Recent Epoch

  • 1990xxxx_BerkeleyRacialEthnicShifts80to90.pdf
  • 19920129_SteelEducationalVision.pdf
  • 19920603_Clip_BerkSchoolsBondIssue.pdf
  • 19920625_SOTF_formationMemoFromSup.pdf
  • 19921027_SOFTschedFirstFewMeetings.pdf
  • 19921100_OnpassMapBlackPopDensity.pdf
  • 19921116_workshopInvideUCExperts.pdf
  • 19921123_MapWorkshop_Flyer.pdf
  • 19921124_SOFTMinutes_MonicaModels.pdf
  • 19921124_SOFTMinutes_MonicaModelsCharts200dpi.pdf
  • 19921992_MapWorkshopAgenda.pdf
  • 1992____clip_PreTaskForceSchoolsFacerChanges.pdf
  • 1992____maybe_clip_SchoolsToRethinkBusing.pdf
  • 901001_SeismicEvalExecSummary.pdf
  • 901200_LettersReleasesStrategicPlanning90-91.pdf
  • 911021_StrategicPlanningLetttersNews.pdf
  • 921203_RestructOfBUSDFocusesOnLocalControl.pdf
  • 930121_DesigKeyToBUSDReorg.pdf
  • 930125_BUSD_CommunityRelationsRFP.pdf
  • 930216_FernTigerProposal.pdf
  • 930225_TaskForceConsensusGoesToDistrict.pdf
  • 930303_ExpertWarnsSchoolChoiceMustBeMeticulouslyPlanned.pdf
  • 930407_BUSDTaskForceFaultsDesegSystem.pdf
  • 930422_72ProposalsAddedToPotpourri.pdf
  • 930506_ParentsWantToSeeAction.pdf
  • 9305__FernTigerOutreachList.pdf
  • 9305__SuperPresentsMeasureATimeline.pdf
  • 930709_BerkeleySchoolBoardDefersDecision.pdf
  • 930917_BerkeleySchoolsGoDoorToDoor.pdf
  • 931006_MITandUCBOfferDesignExpertise.pdf
  • 931018_BerkeleySchoolsPlanAnOverhaul.pdf
  • 931111_K5DistPref.pdf
  • 931118_GradeConfigurationDominatesSchoolDebate.pdf
  • 931122_K4ZonesMarkedUp.pdf
  • 931122_K4ZonesMarkedUpColor.pdf
  • 931122_K4ZonesMarkedUpColor_50pc.png
  • 931124_RumorsAboutSchoolChangesWorryParents.pdf
  • 931125_RumorsRallyArtsMagnet.pdf
  • 931130_K5ZoneEachSchool.pdf
  • 931204_APlusNews.pdf
  • 931206_Chart_Urgent.pdf
  • 931206_ESThreeZone.pdf
  • 931206_K5ThreeZoneColumInMiddle.pdf
  • 931206_K5ThreeZoneES.pdf
  • 931206_K5ThreeZoneGross.pdf
  • 931206_ThreeZone.pdf
  • 931206_ThreeZoneUneqCaps.pdf
  • 931210_K5Choice38MileProxim.pdf
  • 931212_K5ThreeZoneEqPopsCragInMiddle.pdf
  • 931212_Map_IfYouBuildIt.pdf
  • 93____FlowChartBUSD2AF2.pdf
  • 93____FlowChartBUSD2AF2.png
  • 93____FlowChartBUSD2AF2_65pc.png
  • 93____FlowChartBUSD4AF2.pdf
  • 19930103_BWpropose_keepCurrent.pdf
  • 19930103_LeConteKeepK3.pdf
  • 19930103_LecontePTANews.pdf
  • 19930105_SOFTAgenda.pdf
  • 19930108_FranklinSiteCommittee.pdf
  • 19930108_GrahamLetterReWCragmontSiteCommittee.pdf
  • 19930111_KittyMcClean_AgainstChoice.pdf
  • 19930113_Clip_DontAbandonDeseg.pdf
  • 19930113____ArticleGuardian.pdf
  • 19930113_clipDontAbandonDeseg.pdf
  • 19930113_clip_express_NeighborhoodSch_versus.pdf
  • 19930121_JanetHusebyToCragCommunity_Letter.pdf
  • 19930125_AgnesFarris_CommunitySchoolsInTransitonAddend.pdf
  • 19930125_WCragmontSiteCommittee.pdf
  • 19930126_ArtsMagnetSiteCommittee.pdf
  • 19930126_SOTFminutes_meeting15.pdf
  • 19930127_JanetHusebyMotionToAmendStatementOne.pdf
  • 19930127_clip_AboutFaceNoguera.pdf
  • 19930128_LetterEd_LizBrown_SpendingMAFunds.pdf
  • 19930208_ChoiceSysProposal_JimMasters.pdf
  • 19930208_LeConteSiteCommittee.pdf
  • 19930208_MalcolmXSiteCommittee.pdf
  • 19930209_JeffersonSiteCommittee.pdf
  • 19930209_K3CurrentBoundaries_BnWDiagram.pdf
  • 19930209_K5ChoiceWDistancePrefs.pdf
  • 19930209_K5ModelDistPref_BnWDiagram.pdf
  • 19930209_OxfordSiteCommittee.pdf
  • 19930217_TaskForceRec_partial.pdf
  • 19930217_TaskForce_AppxB_AssnGradeConfigModels.pdf
  • 19930217_TaskForce_AppxC_ProposalIdeaPapers_List.pdf
  • 19930217_TaskForce_ReadingMaterialsList.pdf
  • 19930217_pressRelease.pdf
  • 19930224_flyer_ClinchWorkshop.pdf
  • 19930225_NogueraColumn_StatusQuoMayBeBest.pdf
  • 19930228_ReportOnLeconteForum.pdf
  • 19930301_clip_MajorChangesUnlikelyIn93.pdf
  • 19930303_CambridgeReportOnControlledChoice.pdf
  • 19930323_SteelAnnouncedMoreWorkshops.pdf
  • 19930430_ArticleExpress.pdf
  • 19930512_ArgsForAndAgainstStatusQuo.pdf
  • 19930513_JeffersonPrincipalsNewsletter.pdf
  • 19930515_clip_NoMeasureAPlanExpectedThisYear.pdf
  • 19930612_agenda_DesignIssuesSymposium.pdf
  • 19930701_articleSteelFacesNeedForChange.pdf
  • 19931006_TomRose_DoNotRebuildCragmontPriorToMoreStudy.pdf
  • 19931010_BWProposalForMosaic.pdf
  • 19931029_RespToQFromHouseMeetnForums.pdf
  • 199310__DistrictByGradeEthnicityGraph.pdf
  • 19931106_KPrenticeProposal.pdf
  • 19931111_K5_showDistancePref.pdf
  • 19931111_LetterToEd_JimMasters.pdf
  • 19931118_Clipping_931118_BerkVoice.pdf
  • 19931118_Clipping_931118_BerkVoice_MITStudents.pdf
  • 19931118_FernTigerWorkshop.pdf
  • 19931127_K3CrescentCharts.pdf
  • 19931127_K5NewZonesCrescent.pdf
  • 19931128_CindyLarsonCragmontPreschoolSurvey.pdf
  • 19931128_ExaminerColumn_ChangingSchools.pdf
  • 19931128_OldZones65pc.png
  • 19931128_oldzones.JPG
  • 19931201_NewZonesKristinPrintice.pdf
  • 19931201_TalkingPointsForSpeakersProMX.pdf
  • 19931203__K4Charts.pdf
  • 19931204_BUSD_FernTiger_MITstudents.pdf
  • 19931206_3Zone_beforeRevelation.pdf
  • 19931206____CrescentCharts.pdf
  • 19931208_Desario_PleaseSaveMX.pdf
  • 19931209_BWSpeech_FairTreatmentForSouthZone.pdf
  • 19931210_3Zone_Revelation.pdf
  • 19931210_QAboutBussing_OaklandTrib.pdf
  • 19931210__BUSD_charts.pdf
  • 19931211_BussingStudyPrelim.pdf
  • 19931211_DistanceStudy.pdf
  • 19931212_BWtoFern_AnswersForOakTrib.pdf
  • 19931212_OakTribFourQuestions.pdf
  • 19931213_BussingStudyForFerm.pdf
  • 19931215Dec15_BUSD_Reconfig.pdf
  • 19931215Dec15_BUSD_Reconfig_ocr.pdf
  • 19931215_Dec15_BUSD_Reconfig.doc
  • 19931215_MinutesSchoolBoard_AdoptionOfPlan.pdf
  • 19931216_SteelToParents_LastNightDecision.pdf
  • 19931231_clip_EBExpress.pdf
  • 199312___MeasANews_Nov_DownToWire_MIT.pdf
  • 199312__earlyDec_maps.pdf
  • 1993_____FernTiger_Flowchart.pdf
  • 1993____clip_NAACPvowsToFightChoice.pdf
  • 19940407_Clipping_SteelListsScenarios.pdf
  • 19940407_clip_ToughDecisionsAsDeadlineNears.pdf
  • 19940701_CIR_ProjectDesc.pdf
  • 19940714_CIR_BUSDdatavsCensus.pdf
  • 19940723_CIR_dropoutStudy.pdf
  • 19941116BUSD_BoardProgress.pdf
  • 19941116_ProgressReportOnReconfigDecisons_Issues_ParentAccess.pdf
  • 19941116_ProgressReportOnReconfigDecisons_portion.pdf
  • 19941210_ApprovalOfReconfig.pdf
  • 19941212_BWpleaDelayOneYear.pdf
  • 19941212_CallForSpeakers_DelayOneYear.pdf
  • 19941212_WicinasPleaDelayOneYear.pdf
  • 19941215_Clipping_RestructuringApproved.pdf
  • 1994___or95_clip_IntegrationPhaseOut.pdf
  • 940713_ColumbusFateToBeDecidedToday.pdf
  • 940720_CragmontRebuildingShouldBringBackPupils.pdf
  • 940819_AngryFlatlandersLookToTheHills.pdf
  • 941201_DoolanShaughnessy.pdf
  • 941201_DoolanShaughnessyIncomeDist.png
  • 941201_DoolanShaughnessyZones.png
  • 941201_MastersOpposesCragmontRebuild.pdf
  • 94planMAP.jpg
  • 19950108_ResponseToBakerQuery.pdf
  • 19950121__clip_BerkeleyRevampsSchoolEnrollment.pdf
  • 19950208_ArtsMagnetNewsletter.pdf
  • 19950227_clip_Chron_SchoolChoiceBigResponse.pdf
  • 19950307_BW_StateOfAssignmentSoftware.pdf
  • 19950309_StatusOfChoiceSoftware.pdf
  • 19950318_clip_mostGetSchoolOfChoice.pdf
  • 19950319_flyer_BerkSchoolsResegregating.pdf
  • 19950509_BUSDVoluntaryPlanToDesgrregate.pdf
  • 19950509_BUSDVoluntaryPlanToDesgrregate_AppnA.pdf
  • 19950509_BUSDVoluntaryPlanToDesgrregate_AppnB.pdf
  • 19950509_BUSDVoluntaryPlanToDesgrregate_AppnC.pdf
  • 19950509_BUSDVoluntaryPlanToDesgrregate_AppnD.pdf
  • 19950509_BUSDVoluntaryPlanToDesgrregate_AppnE.pdf
  • 19950725_report_reviewOfStudentAssignment.pdf
  • 19950725_report_reviewOfStudentAssignment_cont.pdf
  • 1995_____DraftAssignmentPriorities.pdf
  • 1995_____PlanToAchiveRacialDeseg_excerpt_ParentInformation.pdf
  • 1995_____clip_choiceFrustratesSome.pdf
  • 19960218_clipSeattle_MythsAndRealitiesOfSchoolChoice.pdf
  • 19960926_clip_AParentChallengesPolicy.pdf
  • 19961106_BUSDReportOn96_97ReconfigPlan.pdf
  • 19970224_GideonGoldmanQuery.pdf
  • 19980301_ProposedRevisionsDesegPlan_SocEcZones.pdf
  • 19980807magsch.doc
  • 19980810_ProposedStuSelect.pdf
  • 19981013_BrainstormingChangesInAssignment.pdf
  • 19981029_ChoiceProgramPropFullyDetailed.pdf
  • 19981117_SocEcBandsMap.pdf
  • Second Recent Epoch

  • 19990600__OrfieldYun_ResegInAmerSchool_titlePage.pdf
  • 19990616_SupToBoard_ChargeOfCitizensAdvisoryCommDiversity.pdf
  • 19990920_article_SFNewDiversityPlan.pdf
  • 19990920_clipSFSchoolsFloatNewDiversityPlan.pdf
  • 19990922_maps_NeighborhoodSchStudy.pdf
  • 19991004_SocEcBandsModel_forCommittee.pdf
  • 19991006_JackM_IntentionToReviseAssgnPlan.pdf
  • 19991007_members_CitizAdvisorCommitOnDiversity.pdf
  • 19991013_ControlledChoiceMinutes.pdf
  • 19991013_RuizSperow_SocSciResearchOnEffectsOfPoverty.pdf
  • 19991013_myNotes_ControlledChoiceCommittee.pdf
  • 19991014_MeetingSched_ControlledChoiceCommittee.pdf
  • 19991018_RuizSperow_SocSciResearchOnEffectsOfDeseg.pdf
  • 19991025_ControlledChoiceMinutes.pdf
  • 19991025_HoyerToBW_RequestForPrintouts.pdf
  • 19991025_HoyerToDiversityCommittee_PropForSocEcDiversityWChoice.pdf
  • 19991029_IsselToBw_NeighborhoodSchools.pdf
  • 19991100__SummaryOfMinutes_ControlledChoiceCommittee.pdf
  • 19991101_ControlledChoiceCommittee_PedroNoguera.pdf
  • 19991103_article_GroupToRecommendToBoard.pdf
  • 19991103_article_GroupToRecommendToBoard_2.pdf
  • 19991105_VoiceArticle_BUSDdroppingRaceFromAssignment.pdf
  • 19991119_article_DistrictReexaminesPolicy.pdf
  • 19991123_FinalReport_CitizensAdvisoryCommOnDiversity.pdf
  • 19991200__CrainArticle_MeasuringEconDisadvantage.pdf
  • 19991227_RuizSperow_FAXmeasuringEconDisadvan.pdf
  • 001003_SocialSciencePublicationsList.pdf
  • 00BUSD_charts.pdf
  • 20000229_SAAC_schedFirstMeetings.pdf
  • 20000315_JackMc_Methodology_00_01_assgn_plan.pdf
  • 20000315_SupToBoard_AssignMeth00_01_andInfoAboutSocEcBands.pdf
  • 20000405_MissionStatements_successiveDrafts.pdf
  • 20000411_BWMissionStatementVariation.pdf
  • 20000510_SAAC_proposedScheduleAndPrepMaterials.pdf
  • 20000726_SneedMemo_HamptonVsJeffersonCo.pdf
  • 20000731_HistoricBUSDK12Pop.pdf
  • 20001000_RuizSperow_StuAssignmentCases.pdf
  • 20001000_RuizSperow_StuAssignmentCasesCont.pdf
  • 20001000_StrictScrutinyExplanation.pdf
  • 20001017_IllustrationOfStrictScutinyLogic.pdf
  • 20001017_SAACAgenda.doc
  • 20001106_HoyerToDiversityCommittee_PropMoreThoroughStudy.pdf
  • 20001107_SAAC_Minutes_and1999ExitStudy.pdf
  • 20001108_clip_BerkSchMayDropRacialBalance.pdf
  • 20001114_BW_table_RaceEthVsSocEcBands.pdf
  • 20001124_NancyRiddle_BriefHistoryAssignmentPlans.pdf
  • 20001128_SAACPublicForumAgenda.pdf
  • 20001128_SAAC_draft_FileRec_toJackM.pdf
  • 20001130_SAAC_RoiaDraftProposal.pdf
  • 2000____BUSD_charts.pdf
  • 2000____SAACDraft_NewNewCharge.pdf
  • 2000____SAAC_meetingSchedule.pdf
  • 2000____pies.pdf
  • 20010430_SAAC_agenda_asASample.pdf
  • 20010507_SAAC_testRunsVariousScenarios.pdf
  • 20010619_SAACEquity.doc
  • 20010620_SAAC_report_noPlanYet.pdf
  • 20010626_DerickMiller_numberCrunchNeeded.pdf
  • 20010924_CambridgePlan_excerptPerStuAssignment.pdf
  • 20011009_SAACMinutes.pdf
  • 20011016_SAACMinutes.pdf
  • 20011023_earlyAssgnSimulation_perParentEdu.pdf
  • 20011023_memo1001A.doc
  • 20011106_SAAC_beliefStatementSkeleton.pdf
  • 20011106_SAAC_draftStatementOfBeliefs.pdf
  • 20011109_BUSD Belief110901_Sheila.doc
  • 20011218_densityMap_AvgHousePrices.pdf
  • 2001____SAACtabledItems.pdf
  • 20020110_article_CambridgeToDesegBasedOnSE.pdf
  • 20021016_POVERTY STATUS IN 1999.doc
  • 20021016_SAAC Utopia.doc
  • 20021020_piesTwoRound.pdf
  • 20021100_NancyRiddleDraft 1.doc
  • 20021100_ProximityAssignmentSimu.pdf
  • 20021107_emailRoiaFeedbackAtForum.html
  • 20021108_BerkSchoolsMayDropRacialBalancePolicy.pdf
  • 20021108_clipRaceFactorInSchPlacementUnderFire.pdf
  • 20021200_Part II Forum Outline(mini).doc
  • 20021212_FreeReducedMap.pdf
  • 20021213_NeighborhoodQuarterMile.pdf
  • 20021217_BoardMinutesAndSAACReport_BW.pdf
  • 20021217_BoardMinutesAndSAACReport_color.pdf
  • 20021217_BoardMinutesAndSAACReport_wo_diagrams.pdf
  • 200212__SAACReport.pdf
  • 20031002todo.doc
  • 20031106_TrialRuns_SimulationMethodology.pdf
  • 20031124_soecformula.doc
  • 20031222_TrialRuns_SimulationMethodology.doc
  • 20040109_SocEcFactorsAndCombiningMethod.pdf
  • 20040116 STU Assignment Policy.doc
  • 20040121_BUSD_StudentAssignmentPlan.pdf
  • 20040121_BUSD_StudentAssignmentPlanCHART400dpi.pdf
  • 20040205_clip_BerkSchoolsRedrawPlanForIntegration.pdf
  • 20040206_cilp_DespiteLawsuitBoardAdopts.pdf
  • 20040515_article_ResegrationLittleRock.pdf
  • 20070629_Trib_CourtRejectsRaceBasedDiversityPlans.pdf
  • 20090618_clip_StateSurpremeCourtRejectsChallenge.pdf
  • 201508171905.pd931206_K5ThreeZoneUnEq.pdf
  • 950418_SomeFamiliesFindingReconfigur.pdf
  • 950518_FindingASchoolForEverybody.pdf
  • 950720_clip_parentsFrustratedBySchAssign.pdf
  • 951101_NewChoicePlanGetsHighMarks.pdf
  • 961204_EdWeek_SeattleToShelveRaceBasedBussing.pdf
  • 970430_SchoolsPonderHowToPursueDiversity.pdf
  • 970806_EdWeek_NAACPWrestlesWEvolvingViewsOnDeseg.pdf
  • 971009_SeattleTimes_TossStudentAssignmentPlan.pdf
  • 981202_EdWeek_TeachersProposeIntegratingBySocEc.pdf
  • 990331_EdWeek_EconomicSchoolDeseg.pdf
  • 990825_EdWeek_DesegregationQuestioned.pdf
  • AvilaSuitJudgesDecisionDemurr_040406.pdf
  • AvilaSuitJudgesDecision_040406.pdf

  • PieNotes020808.doc
  • Plan_to_Respond_to_Legal_Ch.doc
  • SAAC monitoring plan.doc
  • SIXYEAR.DOC
  • TheLastMonopoly_reCambridgeChoice.pdf
  • Bruce Wicinas Archive